top of page

34th Annual Artie Award Nominations

  • Writer: Anthony Chase
    Anthony Chase
  • 2 hours ago
  • 5 min read

Celebrating the 2024-2025 Buffalo Theater Season

 

34th Annual Artie Award Nominations

Celebrating Excellence in the 2024-2025 Buffalo Theater Season

Sponsored by Buffalo Toronto Public Media

 

OUTSTANDING PRODUCTION OF A PLAY

  • The African Company Presents Richard III, Ujima Theatre Company

  • Dorian, Irish Classical Theatre Company

  • The Hobbit, Theatre of Youth

  • Our Lady of 121st Street, Road Less Traveled Productions

  • The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, Alleyway Theatre

  • The Wanderers, Jewish Repertory Theatre of WNY

 

OUTSTANDING PRODUCTION OF A MUSICAL

  • 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee, 2nd Generation Theatre

  • Hedwig and the Angry Inch, 2nd Generation Theatre

  • Newsies, D’Youville Kavinoky Theatre

  • The Producers, Lancaster Opera House

  • The Prom, MusicalFare Theatre

  • Waitress, MusicalFare Theatre

 

OUTSTANDING DIRECTION OF A PLAY

  • Mason Beggs, Dorian, Irish Classical Theatre Company

  • Chris J Handley, The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, Alleyway Theatre

  • John Hurley, Burn This, Road Less Traveled Productions

  • Kyle LoConti, The Loved Ones, Irish Classical Theatre Company

  • Gabriella McKinley, The Niceties, 2nd Generation Theatre

  • Steve Vaughan, The Wanderers, Jewish Repertory Theatre of WNY

 

OUTSTANDING DIRECTION OF A MUSICAL

  • Susan Drozd, Waitress, MusicalFare Theatre

  • Terri Filips Vaughan, Into the Woods, O’Connell & Company

  • Michael Gilbert-Wachowiak, Hedwig and the Angry Inch, 2nd Generation Theatre

  • Robyn Lee, Sweet Charity, D’Youville Kavinoky Theatre

  • Eric Deeb Weaver, Newsies, D’Youville Kavinoky Theatre

  • Doug Weyand, The Prom, MusicalFare Theatre

 

OUTSTANDING LEADING ACTRESS IN A PLAY

  • Leah Berst, Burn This (Anna), Road Less Traveled Productions

  • Kai Crumley, Early Girl (Lily), Brazen-Faced Varlets

  • Eileen Dugan, The Loved Ones (Nell), Irish Classical Theatre Company

  • Tracie Lane, Scenes from A Marriage (Marianne), Torn Space Theater

  • Anika Pace, The Niceties (Zoe), 2nd Generation Theatre

  • Alexandria Watts, The Wanderers (Sophie), Jewish Repertory Theatre of WNY

 

OUTSTANDING LEADING ACTOR IN A PLAY

  • Kristopher Bartolomeo, Dorian (Dorian et al), Irish Classical Theatre Company

  • Brendan Didio, Dracula: A Comedy of Terrors (Jonathan), Irish Classical Theatre Company

  • Trevor Dugan, The Informer (Gypo), American Repertory Theatre of WNY

  • Peter Johnson, (Rooftop) Our Lady of 121st Street, Road Less Traveled Productions

  • David Lundy, Remember This (Jan), Jewish Repertory Theatre of WNY

  • Brian Tabak, Shawshank Redemption (Andy), Desiderio’s Dinner Theatre

 

OUTSTANDING LEADING ACTOR IN A MUSICAL

  • Merrick Allen, Chess (Anatoly), Lancaster Opera House

  • Vanna Deux, Hedwig and the Angry Inch (Hedwig), 2nd Generation Theatre

  • Connor Hesch, Pippin (Pippin), O’Connell & Company

  • Quinn Christopher McGillion, Bonnie and Clyde (Clyde Barrow), Bellissima Productions

  • Ben Michael Moran, Sweet Charity (the men), D’Youville Kavinoky Theatre

  • Ricky Needham, Something Rotten (Nigel), MusicalFare Theatre

 

OUTSTANDING LEADING ACTRESS IN A MUSICAL

  • Heather Casseri, Into the Woods (The Baker’s Wife), O’Connell & Company

  • Jetaun Louie, Pippin (Player), O’Connell & Company

  • Maria Pedro, Waitress (Jenna), MusicalFare Theatre

  • Jenn Stafford, The Prom (Dee Dee), MusicalFare Theatre

  • Aimee Walker, Sweet Charity (Charity), D’Youville Kavinoky Theatre

  • Emily Yancey, Chess (Florence), Lancaster Opera House

 

OUTSTANDING ENSEMBLE OF A PLAY

  • The Early Girl, Brazen-Faced Varlets

  • Everybody, Ujima Theatre Company

  • The Hobbit, Theatre of Youth

  • The Hung Man, Buffalo United Artists

  • The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, Alleyway Theatre

  • Our Lady of 121st Street, Road Less Traveled Productions

 

OUTSTANDING ENSEMBLE OF A MUSICAL

  • 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee, 2nd Generation Theatre

  • Into the Woods, O’Connell & Company

  • Khan!!!, O’Connell & Company

  • Newsies, D’Youville Kavinoky Theatre

  • The Prom, MusicalFare Theatre

  • Sweet Charity, D’Youville Kavinoky Theatre

 

OUTSTANDING SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A PLAY

  • Todd Benzin, The Winter’s Tale (Polixenes), Shakespeare in Delaware Park

  • Thomas Evans, The Hobbit (Thorin et al), Theatre of Youth

  • Jorge Luna, Dracula: Comedy of Terrors (Dracula), Irish Classical Theatre Company

  • David Marciniak, Witch (Arthur), Road Less Traveled Productions

  • Gerald Ramsey, The African Company Presents Richard III (Papa Shakespeare), Ujima Theatre Company

  • Adam Yellen, The Wanderers (Schmuli), Jewish Repertory Theatre of WNY

 

OUTSTANDING SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A PLAY

  • Arin Lee Dandes, The Wanderers (Esther), Jewish Repertory Theatre of WNY

  • Rebecca Elkin, The Loved Ones (Orla), Irish Classical Theatre Company

  • Anna Fernandez, Private Lives (Sibyl), Irish Classical Theatre Company

  • Anna Kremholtz, The Hobbit (Gandalf et al), Theatre of Youth

  • Sheila McCarthy, The Murder of Roger Ackroyd (Caroline), Alleyway Theatre

  • Ember Tate, The Loved Ones (Gabby), Irish Classical Theatre Company

 

OUTSTANDING SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A MUSICAL

  • Brittany Bassett-Baran, Something Rotten (Bea), MusicalFare Theatre

  • Kelly Copps, The Producers (Ulla), Lancaster Opera House

  • Sam Crystal, Into the Woods (Little Red), O’Connell & Company

  • Amy Jakiel, 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee (Rona), 2nd Generation Theatre

  • Lily Jones, Waitress (Becky), MusicalFare Theatre

  • Ashleigh Chrisena Ricci, Pippin (Catherine), O’Connell & Company

 

OUTSTANDING SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A MUSICAL

  • Kristopher Bartolomeo, Hedwig and the Angry Inch (Yitzhak), 2nd Generation Theatre

  • Steve Copps, 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee (Panch), 2nd Generation Theatre

  • Joe Greenan, Into the Woods (Jack), O’Connell & Company

  • John Kaczorowski, Waitress (Dr. Jim), MusicalFare Theatre

  • Matt Rittler, Newsies (Crutchie), D’Youville Kavinoky Theatre

  • Aaron Gabriel Saldana, Bonnie and Clyde (Buck), Bellissima Productions

 

OUTSTANDING FEATURED PERFORMANCE

  • Caitlin Coleman, The Hung Man (Alfred Hitchcock / Mother), Buffalo United Artists

  • Jeffrey Coyle, Arsenic & Old Lace (Jonathan), Lancaster Opera House

  • Ann DeFazio, The Day I Learned to Fly (Mom), First Look Buffalo

  • Daniel Lendzian, Dracula: Comedy of Terrors (Mina/Van Helsing), Irish Classical Theatre Company

  • Lisa Ludwig, Pippin, (Bertha)  O’Connell & Company

  • Jeremy Ephraim Meyers, Waitress (Ogie), MusicalFare Theatre

 

OUTSTANDING SET DESIGN

  • Dyan Burlingame, Shipwrecked!, Road Less Traveled Productions

  • Chris Cavanagh, Waitress, MusicalFare Theatre

  • David Dwyer, Arsenic and Old Lace, Lancaster Opera House

  • Steve Harter, Monsters of the American Cinema, Buffalo United Artists

  • Andrew Machovec, The Hobbit, Theatre of Youth

  • Collin Ranney, Our Lady of 121st Street, Road Less Traveled Productions

 

OUTSTANDING TECHNICAL ELEMENT

  • Brian Cavanagh, Lighting, The Wanderers, Jewish Repertory Theatre of WNY

  • Chris Cavanagh, Lighting, The Hobbit, Theatre of Youth

  • Lowden Flower, Lighting, Dorian, Irish Classical Theatre Company

  • Tom Makar, Sound, Remember This, Jewish Repertory Theatre of WNY

  • Danielle Rosvally, Fight Direction, Dorian, Irish Classical Theatre Company

  • Emma Schimminger, Lighting, The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, Alleyway Theatre

 

OUTSTANDING COSTUME DESIGN

  • Cassie Cameron, Dracula: A Comedy of Terrors, Irish Classical Theatre Company

  • Kari Drozd, Something Rotten, MusicalFare Theatre

  • Ann R. Emo, The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, Alleyway Theatre

  • Timmy Goodman, Into the Woods, O’Connell & Company

  • Devin Prokop, Hedwig and the Angry Inch, 2nd Generation Theatre

  • Collin Ranney, Dorian, Irish Classical Theatre Company

 

OUTSTANDING CHOREOGRAPHY

  • Joey Bucheker, Pippin, O’Connell & Company

  • Kristy E. Cavanagh, Something Rotten, MusicalFare Theatre

  • Bobby Cooke, Comedy of Errors, Shakespeare in Delaware Park

  • Eric Deeb Weaver, Newsies, D’Youville Kavinoky Theatre

  • Michael Deeb Weaver, Sweet Charity, D’Youville Kavinoky Theatre

  • Tara Kaczorowski, The Wizard of Oz, Lancaster Opera House

 

OUTSTANDING MUSIC DIRECTION

  • Rebecca Kroetsch, Into the Woods, O’Connell & Company

  • Bridget Moriarty, The Fitzgeralds of Saint Paul, Irish Classical Theatre Company

  • Allan Paglia, Newsies, D’Youville Kavinoky Theatre

  • Theresa Quinn, The Prom, MusicalFare Theatre

  • Dominic Vesely, Bonnie and Clyde, Bellissima Productions

 

EMANUEL FRIED AWARD FOR OUTSTANDING NEW PLAY

  • Lara Haberberger, Shylock, American Repertory Theatre of WNY

  • Donna Hoke, Brilliant Works of Art, Bellissima Productions

  • Mark Humphrey, The Break Song, American Repertory Theatre of WNY

  • Matthew LaChiusa, The Informer, American Repertory Theatre of WNY

  • Bella Poynton, The Mighty Maisie, American Repertory Theatre of WNY

 

CAREER ACHIEVEMENT AWARD

Eileen Dugan


Tickets are on sale now:




 

 
 

©2025 by Theater Talk Buffalo

Buffalo, NY, USA

bottom of page